I bought a set of these a couple of weeks ago, before I even saw this thread, but haven't put them in yet. For $28 shipped I figured I can't go wrong. I've been getting water in the driver side. Car's going to the body shop to fix some minor accident damage to rear pass QP, and that's not even happening until June. So just in case the shop needs to pull a taillight(s) for any reason, I don't wanna put the gaskets in. I want to put them in once, and that's it. Because once the origional seal is made, if you take the gaskets out and put it back in, the seal is never as good again.