DC2 Hopeful said:
adding a bypass valve to a cold air intake makes it nothing more than a show piece because it takes away all the gains you would've gotten.
I seriously doubt that it true. Why the heck would AEM design a bypass valve that completely negates all the advantages of getting their CAI in the first place? Does that make sense to anyone?
Now, my personal opinion, the risk of sucking up water with a CAI is overblown. I had a AEM CAI in my GSR for 3 years and 30K miles, never sucked up water. And I had a few instances where I thought I might, really big puddles. I'm in N.H. too, plenty of rain to go around up here. The part of the pass. side wheel well lining that extends forward to the front bumper protects the filter really well from keeping any large amount of water from hitting it. If you've installed one you know what I mean. You would need to hit and VERY LARGE, DEEP puddle at HIGH SPEED to get enough water to the filter where it may suck it through the filter and to the engine. As long as you have a pass. side wheel well liner that you put back in correctly (not missing a bunch of fasteners and just flapping around under there) after installing the CAI, don't worry about water.
"Short ram is better at high end and cold air is better for low end. "
That's true, but this isn't 100% accurate....
"Anyone that tries to tell you "cold air means it sucks in colder air from under the car" is lying, the difference in temperature is negligable.
When the car isn't moving, the air behind the pass. side corner lens IS going to be colder than under the hood. Once the car is moving, the air temperature in these two locations is indeed negligible. That cooler air at launch/low speed, the piping size being smaller and the 4K rpm "hump" are the reasons CAI is better than a SRI for low end/midrange. SRI's are better for high end because underhood temperature vs. front bumper temperature are virtually the same at constant speed, and because the larger diameter, shorter legnth piping of the SRI allows for better throttle response and a larger volume of air to be drawn into the TB at high rpm vs. the longer, thinner piping of a CAI.
When your engines screaming at over 6,000 rpm, it's gonna want to be sucking air through a short fat straw, not a long skinny one, to get all the air it can to keep creating power as rpm's climb and airflow speed and quantity demand increases. But when it's just sipping air a idle/low rpm's, the long thin straw works best.